Average Rent in Fire Island, NY

Home » NY » Fire Island » Fire Island

Current Versus Historical Fire Island, NY Rents

Fire Island rentals average $4,000 for a studio rental to $9,000 for a 4-bedroom rental. The median price of all currently available listings is $8,450, or roughly $67 per square feet.

For the apartment units and housing in October 2026, median rents have fallen substantially over the last year. Studio rentals prices have increased by $0 (0.00%) year-over-year from $4,000 to $4,000. 1-bedroom rentals prices have decreased by $10,600 (-75.18%) year-over-year from $14,100 to $3,500. 2-bedroom rentals prices have decreased by $250 (-4.42%) year-over-year from $5,650 to $5,400. 3-bedroom rentals prices have decreased by $225 (-3.57%) year-over-year from $6,300 to $6,075. 4-bedroom rentals prices have increased by $833 (10.20%) year-over-year from $8,167 to $9,000. Note that this figure includes all active and rented listings throughout the month.

Month-to-month, seasonality might have a bigger impact than overall trend price changes. Studio rents have gone down by 0.00% this month. 1-bedroom rents have gone down by 67.19% this month. 2-bedroom rents have gone up by 0.62% this month. 3-bedroom rents have gone down by 0.41% this month. 4-bedroom rents have gone down by 1.01% this month.

Beds	Price / Sqft	Oct 2026 Rent	1 Yr Ago Rent (% +/-)	3 Yr Ago Rent (% +/-)
Studio	N/A	$4,000	$4,000 (0.00%)	$4,000 (0%)
1 BR	$36.48	$3,500	$14,100 (-75.18%)	$28,587 (-87.76%)
2 BR	$61.80	$5,400	$5,650 (-4.42%)	$20,700 (-73.91%)
3 BR	$63.16	$6,075	$6,300 (-3.57%)	$6,389 (-4.91%)
4+ BR	$78.26	$9,000	$8,167 (10.20%)	$7,333 (22.73%)

Historical Rents in Fire Island, NY

Studio

1 Bed

2 Bed

3 Bed

4 Bed

Top Cities Near Fire Island

There are a total of 11 cities nearby Fire Island. The average rent in Fire Island is currently $3,570 per month. A total of 9 cities nearby have an average rent lower than that. Our records show that Yonkers, NY, with an average rent of $2,764, is the most affordable city nearby. In contrast, the most expensive city near Fire Island, NY is Westhampton Beach, NY. Monthly rents here are on average $35,000 per month.

Let's compare Fire Island, NY's rent against other top cities nearby by bedroom size. Typically, rent for studios in Fire Island, NY is 50.00% more expensive than other cities nearby. One bedrooms are about 14.64% more expensive. Two bedrooms in Fire Island, NY are about 37.04% more expensive. Finally, rent for three bedrooms are about 29.63% more expensive. Want more information? Check out the top 10 cities out of 11 total cities near Fire Island, NY in the following table.

City	Studio	1 Bed	2 Bed	All
Yonkers, NY	$2,029	$2,300	$2,550	$2,764
Fort Lee, NJ	$1,560	$2,350	$2,900	$2,850
Coram, NY	$2,000	$2,350	$3,190	$3,133
Long Beach, NY	$2,250	$2,700	$3,375	$3,400
Glen Cove, NY	$2,650	$2,988	$3,400	$3,570
New York, NY	$3,900	$4,782	$6,275	$4,950
Ocean Beach, NY	N/A	$3,500	$4,000	$8,000
Fire Island, NY	$4,000	$3,500	$5,400	$8,450
Hampton Bays, NY	N/A	$4,200	$4,400	$12,250
Westhampton Beach, NY	N/A	$5,000	$18,000	$35,000

Top Neighborhoods Near Fire Island

There are a total of 69 neighborhoods in or near Fire Island. Some of these neighborhoods include Jackson Heights, Nodine Hill, and Getty Square. We've included the top 30 neighborhoods out of 69 total neighborhoods in or near Fire Island, NY in the following table.

The average rent for these 30 neighborhoods in or near Fire Island, NY is currently around $4,650 per month. A total of 69 neighborhoods have a lower average rent. Interestingly, the neighborhoods' average rent is less than Fire Island's average rent, which is actually $8,450. Out of all the neighborhoods in or near Fire Island, Jackson Heights has the most affordable average rent at $2,500 per month. Whereas, at $8,095 average rent per month, Tribeca is the most expensive neighborhood in or near Fire Island. View the following table for more information.

Neighborhood	Studio	1 Bed	2 Bed	All
Jackson Heights, New York, NY	$2,200	$2,500	$2,925	$2,500
Nodine Hill, Yonkers, NY	$1,950	$2,220	$2,450	$2,600
Getty Square, Yonkers, NY	N/A	$2,240	$2,600	$2,700
Inwood, New York, NY	$2,585	$2,900	$3,700	$2,900
Flushing, New York, NY	$2,850	$2,890	$3,900	$2,998
East Flatbush, New York, NY	$61,250	$2,609	$2,940	$3,000
East End South, Long Beach, NY	$2,250	$2,700	$3,200	$3,050
East New York, New York, NY	$2,886	$2,725	$2,875	$3,100
Jamaica, New York, NY	$1,650	$2,863	$3,438	$3,200
Bayside, New York, NY	$2,300	$2,450	$2,900	$3,225
Rego Park, New York, NY	$3,228	$2,798	$3,325	$3,235
Mott Haven, New York, NY	$2,985	$3,250	$3,845	$3,250
Flatbush, New York, NY	$3,230	$3,230	$3,550	$3,250
Central Harlem, New York, NY	$2,599	$2,995	$4,284	$3,444
Ocean Hill, New York, NY	$2,100	$2,750	$3,050	$3,500
Washington Heights, New York, NY	$3,096	$2,820	$3,550	$3,500
Bedford-Stuyvesant, New York, NY	$3,225	$3,449	$4,175	$3,600
Forest Hills, New York, NY	$2,853	$3,514	$4,000	$3,650
Astoria, New York, NY	$2,775	$3,400	$4,591	$3,705
Crown Heights, New York, NY	$2,970	$3,478	$4,656	$3,770
Bushwick, New York, NY	$3,124	$3,425	$3,895	$3,900
Ridgewood, New York, NY	$2,600	$3,471	$3,945	$3,945
East Harlem, New York, NY	$3,225	$3,750	$3,495	$3,995
Harlem, New York, NY	$2,828	$3,250	$3,941	$3,995
Long Island City, New York, NY	$3,694	$4,495	$6,540	$4,565
Greenpoint, New York, NY	$3,690	$4,600	$7,000	$4,650
Roosevelt Island, New York, NY	$3,510	$4,200	$5,600	$5,000
Williamsburg, New York, NY	$4,011	$4,995	$5,750	$5,000
Upper East Side, New York, NY	$3,373	$5,000	$7,995	$5,395
Ocean Beach, NY	N/A	$3,500	$4,000	$8,000

Top Counties Near Fire Island

There are a total of 16 counties located by Fire Island, NY. Some of these counties include Babylon, NY, Brookhaven, NY, and Smithtown, NY. The average rent for rentals in these counties is $3,633. That's roughly around $40 per sqft. A total of 15 counties have a lower average rent. The county that is the most affordable is Yonkers, NY. Its average rent per month is $2,764. Vice versa, with an average rent of $25,000, Southampton, NY is the most expensive county by Fire Island, NY.

Typically, rent for studios in Fire Island, NY is 42.69% more expensive than other counties nearby. In comparison, rent for one bedroom listings in Fire Island, NY is 21.79% more expensive than other counties nearby. Finally, rent for two bedrooms in Fire Island, NY is 36.16% more expensive than other counties nearby. We've listed the top 10 counties in the table below.

County	Studio	1 Bed	2 Bed	All
Babylon, NY	$2,045	$2,580	$2,973	$2,850
Brookhaven, NY	$1,980	$2,425	$3,228	$3,165
Smithtown, NY	$2,285	$2,675	$3,285	$3,220
Long Beach, NY	$2,250	$2,700	$3,375	$3,400
Hempstead, NY	$2,250	$2,600	$3,200	$3,525
Glen Cove, NY	$2,650	$2,988	$3,400	$3,570
Islip, NY	$2,220	$2,470	$3,150	$3,695
Huntington, NY	$1,963	$2,775	$3,675	$3,800
Oyster Bay, NY	$35,000	$2,600	$3,495	$4,730
Southampton, NY	$2,450	$3,700	$9,000	$25,000

Top Zipcodes Near Fire Island

There are a total of 49 zipcodes in or near Fire Island, NY. The average rent for all of these zipcodes is $5,050. A total of 48 zipcodes have an average rent that is lower than that. The zipcode with the most affordable average rent for apartment listings is 10701, Yonkers, NY at $2,600 per month. In comparison, the zipcode with the most expensive average rent of $8,848 per month is 10069, New York, NY.

Studios in these zipcodes have an average rent of $3,690. That's at least $97 per sqft. Do you need more space than that? Average rent for one bedroom rentals for the zipcodes in or near Fire Island, NY is $4,750 per month. Or in other words, $89 per sqft. Meanwhile, two bedroom apartments will cost you an average of $6,578 per month. Which comes out to $87 per sqft. The following table includes the top 10 zipcodes in Fire Island, NY. You can view the average rent breakdown for each zipcode by bedroom size.

Zipcode	Studio	1 Bed	2 Bed	All
11375, New York, NY	$2,853	$3,528	$4,000	$3,656
11237, New York, NY	N/A	$3,475	$3,799	$3,895
11221, New York, NY	$3,124	$3,250	$3,850	$4,000
10701, Yonkers, NY	$2,108	$2,300	$2,500	$2,600
11213, New York, NY	$2,550	$2,995	$3,845	$3,300
11101, New York, NY	$3,694	$4,500	$6,570	$4,634
11206, New York, NY	$3,228	$3,603	$4,195	$4,195
11222, New York, NY	$3,690	$4,600	$6,877	$4,625
11216, New York, NY	$3,250	$3,495	$4,500	$3,600
10029, New York, NY	$3,225	$3,700	$3,495	$4,050

Frequently Asked Questions - Fire Island Average Rents

What is the average rent price in Fire Island, NY?

The average monthly rental price for Fire Island, NY apartments for rent is approximately $8,450. This calculation takes into consideration rental listings of varying bedroom/bathroom sizes, building types, and locations.

Do Fire Island, NY rent prices drop in winter?

Yes! On average we see a 3.4% drop in rental prices between the peak summer months and the slower winter months. With the added bonus of decreased competition from other renters looking to move, winter is generally considered the best time of the year to find an apartment for rent in Fire Island, NY.

How much is a studio apartment in Fire Island, NY?

The average monthly rental price for studio apartments is $4,000. There are a total of 1 studio apartment listings currently available for rent in Fire Island.

How much is a one bedroom apartment in Fire Island, NY?

The average monthly rental price for one bedroom apartments is $3,500 and an average price per square feet of $36.48. There are a total of 3 one bedroom apartment listings currently available for rent in Fire Island.

How much is a two bedroom apartment in Fire Island, NY?

The average monthly rental price for two bedroom apartments is $5,400 and an average price per square feet of $61.80. There are a total of 12 two bedroom apartment listings currently available for rent in Fire Island.

How have rent prices in Fire Island, NY changed this year?

Rent prices for rentals in Fire Island, NY can fluctuate yearly. Specifically, studio rental prices have changed by 0.00%, one bedroom rental prices have changed by -0.75%, two bedroom rental prices have changed by -0.04%, three bedroom rental prices have changed by -0.04% year-over-year.

What is a reasonable rent price in Fire Island, NY?

A reasonable rent price in Fire Island, NY is around $6,760/month. You can search for these reasonably priced rental listings on RentHop.